Selling gold

What a Buyer Deducts From Your Gold (Stones, Springs and Clasps)

Published 9 October 2026 · 6 min read

A buyer pays only for the gold they can recover. Before any percentage is applied, they take off everything in your piece that isn't gold. That means gemstones, the steel spring inside a clasp, base-metal pins and fittings, and anything packed inside a hollow item. Then they pay a share of the melt value of what is left. UK buyers that publish their prices were paying between 83% and 92% of melt for gold in October 2026. If you weighed a ring with its stones still set, your own figure is too high, so the offer will look worse than it is.

Why is my gold offer lower than the calculator showed?

There are usually three gaps between the number you worked out at home and the one a buyer quotes.

  • The rate. No one pays the full melt value. The buyer keeps a margin to cover testing, refining and the risk of the price moving. That gap is the percentage.
  • The weight. Your scale weighed the whole object. The buyer prices the gold in it, which can be a good deal less.
  • The grade. If carats are mixed, untested or partly plated, the buyer may price some or all of the lot at a lower fineness than you assumed.

The first gap is published and easy to compare. The other two are where misunderstandings happen, and where a written breakdown matters most.

Stones and settings

Gemstones are weighed in metric carats, and one metric carat is a fifth of a gram. A half-carat diamond therefore adds only 0.1 g to a ring, and a single small stone hardly moves the figure. Cluster rings, eternity rings and cocktail rings are different. In those, and in anything set with large coloured stones, glass or cubic zirconia, the stones can make up a real share of the weight.

A buyer will either prise the stones out and weigh the bare metal, or estimate their weight and subtract it. Ask in advance which they do, and whether you get the stones back. A scrap buyer pays nothing for stones, so show a ring with a diamond of any size to a jeweller first. A stone sold on its own may be worth more than the gold around it.

Springs, pins and parts that were never gold

Plenty of gold jewellery contains small pieces of other metal, because steel makes a better spring than soft gold does.

  • Bolt rings and lobster clasps hide a tiny steel spring. On a heavy chain it hardly matters; on a fine one it is a noticeable fraction.
  • Brooch pins, cufflink swivels and watch parts are often steel. A gold watch case is gold, but the movement, glass and many backs are not.
  • Earring backs may be a lower carat, silver or base metal, even when the earrings themselves are hallmarked.
  • Lockets can hold glass, photographs and backing card.
  • Hollow bangles and some heavy-looking rings may be filled to give them body. A buyer who cuts one open will deduct the filling.

Take out what you can yourself, such as photos from a locket or a pendant from a chain. Weigh the pieces separately so nothing is priced at the wrong carat.

Mixed carats, repairs and testing

A bag of mixed jewellery is often priced at the lowest carat in it unless you sort it first. Keep 9ct, 14ct, 18ct and 22ct apart, and put unmarked pieces in a pile of their own. Unhallmarked items are tested before anyone pays, and if a buyer cannot be sure of the fineness they will price it cautiously.

Old repairs can also lower the figure. A resized ring or a soldered chain may carry joints of a different alloy, and a buyer pays for the piece as tested. Gold-plated parts count for nothing at all.

A worked example: one ring, three numbers

This example is invented to show how the deductions stack up. An 18ct cluster ring weighs 5.2 g on a jewellery scale. It holds stones totalling 3 carats, which is 0.6 g.

Example: 18ct ringToday
Your sum: 5.2 g × 0.750, stones included£394.38
Melt value of the gold alone: 4.6 g × 0.750£348.87
Paid at the lowest published rate (83%)£289.56
Paid at the median published rate (91%)£317.47
Paid at the highest published rate (92%)£320.96

Compared with the first line, even the best offer looks low. Compared with the second, it is a fair one. The stones accounted for part of the difference before the buyer's rate came in.

Mixing carats costs more. Say the same seller also has 10 g of 18ct and 10 g of 9ct in one bag. Priced correctly, that is £758.42 plus £379.21 of gold. Priced as 20 g of 9ct, it is only £758.42, a third less, before any rate is applied.

What's a fair price for scrap gold?

Judge any offer on two things: the rate, which should sit within what buyers publish, and the net weight it is applied to. Ask for a quote in writing that shows:

  1. the gross weight of each item;
  2. what was deducted and why, with the weight of each deduction;
  3. the net gold weight and the carat used for it;
  4. the price per gram, the total, and any fees such as postage, insurance, admin or return charges.

Then run the net weight through our gold calculator. If the offer falls below 83% of melt on the net weight, the lowest published rate this month, get a second quote. If the rate looks fine but the net weight seems light, ask to see the items weighed again. Why buyers take a percentage at all is explained in what dealers actually pay. The post on valuing a gold ring walks through a plain band.

Questions about buyer deductions

Why is my gold offer lower than my calculation?
Usually for three reasons: the buyer pays a percentage of melt value, not all of it; they deduct anything that isn't gold, such as stones and steel springs; and mixed or untested pieces may be priced at a lower carat. Buyers that publish their prices paid about 83–92% of melt for gold (October 2026).
Do gold buyers pay for diamonds and other stones?
A scrap buyer normally pays only for the metal and deducts the weight of the stones. A metric carat is a fifth of a gram. Show a ring with a sizeable diamond to a jeweller before selling it as scrap.
Will a buyer deduct the clasp on my chain?
They may deduct the steel spring inside a bolt ring or lobster clasp. With a chunky chain the spring barely registers; with a fine one it is a bigger share of the weight.
How do I know the deductions are fair?
Ask for a written quote listing each item's gross weight, every deduction, the net gold weight, the carat and the price per gram. Check the net weight with a calculator and get a second quote if the figures don't add up.

Every figure on this page is an example worked out from live prices. Only a buyer's own quote is a real offer, and none of this is financial advice.

Value your gold now →