Compare

Pawnbroker vs Gold Dealer vs Online Buyer: Who Pays the Most in the UK?

Published July 2026 · 7 min read

A pawnbroker, a high-street gold shop, an online buyer and a bullion dealer can offer very different sums for the same gold. The quickest option isn't always the one that pays best. To find who pays the most in the UK, turn every offer into a percentage of melt value. Then compare the four routes side by side.

The four routes at a glance

Judge every offer as a percentage of your item's melt value. Melt value is the worth of the pure gold in it at today's spot price. The table shows what is known about what each type of buyer pays.

RouteWhat they pay (% of melt)Best for
PawnbrokerNot published, ask for a written quoteFast cash, or a loan when you want the item back
High-street / cash-for-goldNot published, ask for a written quoteSpeed and convenience on small amounts
Online buyer that publishes its prices83–92% for gold (October 2026)Most scrap jewellery, a price you can check before you post
Specialist bullion dealerVaries, ask for a written quoteLarger lots, coins and bars

Before you weigh up any of them, get your melt value from our gold calculator. That is the ceiling every offer is measured against. The gold price per gram by carat gives today's figure for each standard. If a stamp has you puzzled, start with what 375 means or what 750 means.

Pawnbrokers

Pawnbrokers offer two things: an outright sale, or a loan against your gold that lets you buy it back later. If you only need cash and never want the item again, the sale price is what matters. Pawnbrokers don't publish their rates. For a straight sale of scrap, ask for a written quote and compare it with the rates online buyers publish. The loan suits a piece with sentimental value that you expect to redeem. You'll pay interest on it, and if you can't repay, the pawnbroker keeps the item. A pawnbroker is quick and local, with no posting and no waiting for a cheque. You can pay for that convenience in a lower price. Know your melt value before you go. A pawnbroker's first figure is only an opening offer, and there's often room to push it up.

High-street cash-for-gold shops

Cash-for-gold buyers are the shops with "we buy gold" in the window, and the firms that send you a freepost envelope with a pre-printed cheque. Some are fair; many rely on customers not knowing their melt value. Most stories of gold worth hundreds being valued at a fraction of that come from this route. There's more on why that happens in our piece on what dealers actually pay. If you use one, know your melt value first and never accept a single lump-sum figure without an itemised breakdown.

Check a quick cash offer first The quicker and easier a route feels, the more you're usually paying for it. Before you walk out with cash in ten minutes, check the offer against the rates UK buyers publish: 83–92% of melt for gold in October 2026.

Online mail-in refiners

Online mail-in refiners suit most people selling scrap jewellery. UK buyers who publish their prices paid between 83% and 92% of melt value for gold when we last checked (October 2026). They can pay well for four reasons:

  • Refinery scale. They process huge volumes, so the fixed costs of assaying and refining are spread thin across every gram.
  • Low overheads. No prime-location shopfront, no high-street rent, fewer staff. Those savings can go into your payout instead.
  • Published rates. The reputable ones list exactly what they pay per gram, per carat, on their website, so you can compare before you commit.
  • Insured, returnable parcels. You post your gold in a fully insured, tracked pack, and if you don't like the quote, they return it, also insured.

The trade-off is that you wait a few days and you're trusting the post. Only use a buyer that offers insured, tracked delivery both ways. Done right, it gives you a published price to measure every other offer against.

Specialist bullion dealers

If you've got larger quantities, investment coins or bars, ask a specialist bullion dealer for a written quote. Legal-tender coins such as Sovereigns and Britannias can sell near spot, because they're traded as investment products rather than melted down. Bullion dealers know what they're handling and price it to match. They may be less interested in a bag of mixed broken jewellery. For coins, bars or a large weight of scrap, they're well worth a quote. A Sovereign is 22 carat (see 916 gold), and a gold Britannia made since 2013 is 999.9 fine (see 999 gold). Check which you hold before you ask.

How to compare offers fairly

To compare offers fairly, convert every offer into a percentage of melt. A quote in pounds means nothing until you set it against melt value. Take 40 g of 9ct gold: at today's price of £3,145.26 an ounce its melt value is £1,516.84. At 83% of melt, the lowest rate UK buyers published in October 2026, that's £1,258.97; at 92%, the highest, it's £1,395.49. Any quote can be checked the same way, in four steps:

  1. Get your melt value first, sorted by carat.
  2. Ask every buyer for a written, itemised quote: price per gram, per carat.
  3. Divide each total by your melt value to get the payout percentage.
  4. Sell to the highest percentage from a buyer you trust, not the nearest one.

If an offer is below the lowest rate UK buyers publish (about 83% of melt for gold), get another quote before you accept. Our explainer on spot price vs realistic payout covers why so many people accept less.

The bottom line For scrap jewellery, a buyer that publishes its prices lets you check the rate before you post. For coins, bars or larger lots, get a written quote from a specialist bullion dealer too. Pawnbrokers and high-street shops don't publish their rates, so get a written quote and compare it.

There's no single "best place to sell gold" that suits everyone. One method works for every route. Know your melt value, get itemised quotes from more than one buyer, compare them as percentages, and don't pay for convenience you didn't want. Whichever route you choose, you'll then know you got a fair share of what your gold is worth.

Pawnbroker, dealer or online: your questions

Who pays the highest price for gold in the UK?
There isn't one kind of buyer that always tops the others, and the best gold selling price is simply the highest share of melt you're offered in writing. Of the UK buyers that publish their buying prices, the best price paid for gold that we found in October 2026 was 92% of melt value for gold. Pawnbrokers and shops that don't publish a rate can only be judged by a written quote, set against your melt value.
Do pawnbrokers pay less for gold than online buyers?
We can't say for certain, because pawnbrokers don't publish their buying prices. What you can do is get a written figure from the pawnbroker, work it out as a percentage of melt and put it next to the published online rates. The higher percentage wins, wherever it comes from.
Where can I get a gold valuation in the UK?
For a scrap value, you can do it yourself: weigh the piece, read the hallmark and enter both in the gold calculator. For anything antique, signed by a maker or set with good stones, a jeweller's valuation or an auction house is the better place, since a scrap buyer pays only for the metal.
How do I sell gold jewellery in the UK?
Group the pieces by carat, weigh every group and write down the melt value. Ask two or three buyers for itemised written quotes, turn each into a percentage of melt, and pick the best one from a buyer you trust. If you post it, use insured, tracked delivery both ways.
What will 1 oz of gold sell for?
A troy ounce of 24ct gold has a melt value close to the spot price, which is £3,145.26 as this page loads. At the published buyer rates that comes to about £2,607.96 to £2,890.75. For a bullion coin or bar, ask a bullion dealer for a written quote as well.

All figures are estimates of melt value, never offers. Not financial or tax advice.

Value your gold now →